Communicative Body: origins of MODERN PRIMITIVISM
As members of Western culture are more constrained by external, impersonal forms of social control, the body has become the singular focus of SELF-CONTROL
and IDENTITY. Modern primitivism is a feature of POPULAR CULTURE in association with renewed concerns about environmental issues as well as a sentimental fascination about so called "primitive" peoples. Call against the destruction of the "environment"
- molding, marking and shaping the body in different cultures signifies STATUS and status changes
- may be permanent or temporary
- body is used as an expressive medium and dressed distinctively to present a spectacular self that expresses a distinct group identity
- against middle-class forms of body conduct
- mostly working class men who first did this
- girls: fashion and makeup (surface and temporary)
- body is a vehicle for fashion to combat decay and deterioration…the body is a vehicle for pleasure and self-expression
- emphasize LUDIC and GROTESQUE in opposition to the dominant culture.
- piercing
- tattooing
- branding
- TATTOOED BODY
- scarification, tattooing and piercing all overturn ideals of bodily presentation in Western culture and contexts.
- WESTERN: focus on the elaboration of ones own body (contrary to non-Western contexts).
- usually associated with marginal groups. So what does it mean when they are used by those who are not marginals to deliberately mark themselves? (pirates, criminals, social deviants)
- disassociation from those that lead conventional lives
- rite of passage
- women tend to use them more in private contexts and men display them in public contexts
- way to remind oneself of individuality and personal experience in a culture where this is so important and where making distinctions allows you to feel connected. (individuation)
- Way to identify themselves and give them "magical qualities"
- DECORATION & Asthetic
- example of the body as an unfinished product
- FASHION
-
- visible as well as intimate parts of the body
- homosexulaization
- fascination with non-Western cultures (modern primitivism)
- a way of signaling discontent with modern society and confronting notions of deviance in Western culture through association with the primitive. (against dominant norms and recaptures the sensual self)
- EXTREME BODIES EXTREME CULTURE (etched cultural aesthetics into the body
- Nilotic people of Africa: facial scarification is a way to mark ethnic affiliation
- Wodaabe men of northern Nigeria paint their faces in elaborate colorful patterns that are judged as more or less beautiful by their female suitors
- Wodaabe women adorn their faces with permanent tattoos which enhance their beauty and protect them from the evil eye
- Polynesia: body tattoos are a means of ethnic identification and serve to decalre status and rank and relationship
- Although many of these practices may seem exceptionally invasive and
painful to us, they are seen as rites of passage for young adults. After all, if they can handle the suffering of
the modification, they can handle the challenges of being an adult in
their community, making us think that bar mitzvahs aren’t so bad after
all!
- Body-mod tourism isn’t as rare as you’d
think and it’s controversial. Although an influx of tourists has brought
wealth to impoverished tribes and attention to cultural practices, some
argue it has also led to a deteriorating way of life for many rural
people or the cheapening of certain traditions.
Neck Rings
The practice of wearing neck rings originated in
Burma with a few small subset groups of the
Kayan Tribe. Although the
Kayan tribe as a whole was located in what is now
Myanmar for hundreds
of years, they were forced to flee to Thailand in the sixties and
seventies because of military conflict.
Most Kayans lived for a
short time along the Thai border in refugee camps and were soon placed
in permanent homes by the
Thai government. Shockingly, the Kayan women
who wear neck rings were singled out of the masses of Burmese refugees
and settled in a neighboring camp and have never left. Many sources
report that the Thai government did this so the women could be used for
tourism purposes, which explains why neck rings are now associated with
Thai culture. According to a
BBC report, today
most of these women are stuck in limbo working at tourist-trap
villages, posing for pictures, and are unable to move on due to
complicated (and seemingly malicious) bureaucratic Thai refugee laws.
Although
you can see these women in their villages around the city of Mae Hong
Son on the Burma-Thailand border, be prepared for a tourist trap that
may look more like a human zoo than a traditional village.
Lip Plates
Although
there are many independent cultures who have at some point donned lip
plates, there is only one remaining tribe that still actively practices
lip stretching: the
Mursi tribe in Ethiopia. According to tradition, six
months to a year before a girl is to be married, a small incision is
made in the middle of her bottom lip and a stick is put in. Slowly over
time, larger disks are inserted until her lip is stretched big enough to
be used for a basketball hoop. In addition, many girls have their two
lower teeth knocked out to accommodate the huge plate.
Rationale
behind this practice is unclear to anthropologists. Other than the
inherent disfigurement and pain, many Mursi women have trouble speaking
normally and often drool since they essentially have no lip or teeth on
the bottom of their mouth. One Darwinian-ish theory is that the practice
was started so women could prove their strength, and therefore worth,
as wives and
mothers. The bigger
the lip plate, the more physical strife the woman is able to withstand,
and the stronger she’ll be as a partner to her husband.
Although
there are many unknowns about lip plates, one thing is for sure: Mursi
men seem to love it. For the women of this tribe, getting a lip plate is
the only hope they have for a decent marriage: the bigger the lip, the
more desirable a woman is, and the more cattle the groom’s family has to
“trade” for him to get a wife.
Along with limited marriage
potential if they chose a life sans lip plate, Mursi women also face
added pressure from the outside world to continue with the practice.
Currently the Mursi struggle to survive economically and face drought
and worsening agricultural conditions. Ironically, their lip plates and
reputation as an “untouched” African people have led to an exceptional
amount of tourism in their home in the Omo Valley of Ethiopia and are
currently helping to sustain the Mursi financially.
San Yak Tattoos
They may be extra trendy these days (think Angelina’s
vertical tattoo that runs down her back), but
San Yak tattoos have
adorned the holy and superstitious for hundreds of years in
Thailand and
Cambodia. Traditionally the tattoos are a mix of Buddhist prayers,
images, and shamanistic spells that have survived from the pre-Buddhist,
Hindu religion in Southeast Asia.
Because of the religious
nature of these tattoos, holy men, or even Buddhist monks themselves,
will tattoo people using the traditional method of long metal needles,
tapping ink deep under the skin. The level of detail the tattoo artists
are able to achieve is stunning given the rudimentary tools, but the
popularity of these tattoos aren’t just for their aesthetic appeal. Like
religious amulets, San Yak tattoos are believed to ward off evil
spirits and give their owner ridiculous amounts of luck. The more the
better, like St. Christopher medals.
You can spot San Yak
tattoos on monks and regular people alike, especially in Southeast-Asian
countries, whose inhabitants need a little luck. Perfect example: the
tattoos are incredibly popular among many Muay Thai boxers.
Nose Plugs
The
Apatani tribe lives in the district of
Arunachal Pradesh, India. The
tribe keeps no written records, but they do have an exceptionally unique
way of identifying their women. Traditionally women get face tattoos
and distinctive nose plugs at an early age, which they wear for the
remainder of their life. According to some anthropologists, they created
this practice in order to make the women unattractive to neighboring
tribes who might otherwise want to kidnap their super-hot women.
Although
this practice has been around for hundreds of years, it’s very quickly
losing popularity. Not many women who were born in the eighties and
beyond have chosen to get nose plugs, so as the older women of the tribe
pass away, so will the tradition.
Scarification
Scarification,
or the practice of making permanent scars for aesthetic reasons, is
traditional in many parts of Africa. Although Westerners might balk at
the thought, many tribes in
Northeast Africa see being marked as a rite
of passage. Scars can denote age, social status, wealth, or increase a
person’s sexual attraction. (Really, are fake boobs that much less of a
body modification?) Most scarification is made in repeating, geometric
patterns by cutting the skin, and then rubbing ash or acidic juice into
the wound to assist in creating a lasting scar. Marks on the face, back,
belly, legs (pretty much anywhere) are common.
The lip-plate
sporting
Mursi tribe also liberally practices scarification, and for
this practice both men and women are invited to join in the fun.
Nuer
people in Sudan are famous for their geometric facial scarification.
They receive scars as a mark of adulthood in the tribe. It is believed
if they can sustain this process, they are ready to be respected as
grown ups. Different subsets of the Nuer tribe make their own unique
markings; certain subsets draw six lines across young men’s foreheads,
while others utilize geometric designs to make their mark.
Foot Binding
The ecstacy experienced by Chinese men upon seeing or fondling a lotus foot was the equivalent of that experienced by Western men upon seeing or fondling a female breast.The Chinese also believed however that foot binding had a special bonus, namely it caused layer after layer of folds to develop in the vagina, resulting in a supernatural exaltation during intercourse. The inability to walk also supposedly caused women's thighs to become sensually heavier and caused the genital region to tighten.
this was a symbol of HIGH STATUS, since a family always wanted their daughters feet to be as small as possible, but had to weigh this against practicality, since the economic well being of the family may be dependent upon her ability to work.
Manufactured Bodies
- Cosmetic Surgery in the West
- breast enhancement, concealment and reduction
- sexual organs enhanced by both sexes (labia size decreased and penis size increased)
- collectively express conformity to an ideal body type
- Cosmetic Adornment in the West
- tanning
- nail salons
- hair salons
- full body waxing
Tanned Body
- two competing frames for interpretation
- the medical frame
- sees the medical dangers of tanning in relation to skin cancers
- the seduction frame
- sees the value of tanning as symbolic capitol for the sexualized body (METAPHORICAL EXCHANGE VALUE OF A TANNED BODY)
- tanning as healthy, fit and sexy
- only the tanned WHITE body matters
- gendered, but men can tan if they are
- metrosexual and concerned with their looks and grooming
- gym rats and concerned with how their muscles look
- Frames inform one another but show from a symbolic interactioninst perspective how one's body is viewed from the perspective of how others view it when it is displayed.
- features & factors
- pre-tanning for display on special occasions
- pre-tnning because it makes you feel skinny (female) or shows off your muscles (male)
- body is constantly changed through technological advances which blur the line between "natural" and "fake"
- natural is still better, but not always desired
EXTREME BODIES & EXTREME CULTURE
- a particular set of practices, ideas, images and commodities that surfaced in the last decades of the twentieth century that revolved around the ideas of physical engagement, competition and rick (phenomenological approach to analysis)
- extreme bodies engage in practices and regimes that push beyond the mundane and acceptable. Extreme bodies are the product of excessive physical modification, transformation, or activity, and are also aware of , and accept the physical risks that come with radical carnal engagement. (experience in the body)
- cultural context
- generation x: grappling with an uncertain future
- extreme sports-X games
- about an embodied experience that involves an intense engagement of the senses that is beyond the ordinary
- heightened level of physical engagement in the world.
- proposes that the body and the mind must be awakened to achieve a type of embodied metaphysical nirvana
- lust for life is implied
- the body is an entity which is a project. We are responsible for the shaping of this project through various embodied experiences. (no pain, no gain)
- site for reinvention, renovation and modification
- Not all bodies are alike or have the same capacity for experimentation (the body is a biological, social, psychological and symbolic entity)
- race
- gender
- disability
- physical characteristics
- age
- health
- Bodies are constantly expected to be upgraded
- New views of the body are influenced by
- interiorized body
- spectacularized body (before and after)
- the swan
- extreme makeover
- biggest loser
- I want a famous face